Based on 15,022 Google and Yelp reviews, the top-rated used car dealer in Frankford, Tacony and Mayfair right now is Cartiviti Auto Sales (9.7 out of 10). We rated 15 dealers in Frankford Avenue, Torresdale Avenue and Harbison Avenue — the busiest used car strip in the city. Reviews checked October 31, 2026.
Top-rated dealers
#19.7out of 10
Cartiviti Auto Sales
5800 E Roosevelt Blvd, Philadelphia, PA
Google 4.9★ · 182 reviews
#29.6out of 10
Naryan Auto Group
7525 Frankford Ave, Philadelphia, PA
Google 4.8★ · 2,269 reviews
#39.6out of 10
Danis Auto
6250 Harbison Ave, Philadelphia, PA
Google 4.8★ · 3,468 reviewsYelp 2.9★ · 34 reviews
#49.5out of 10
Go Metro Auto
6601 Frankford Ave, Philadelphia, PA
Google 4.9★ · 88 reviews
#59.4out of 10
Mainline Auto
4075 Torresdale Ave, Philadelphia, PA
Google 4.7★ · 1,398 reviewsYelp 4.0★ · 8 reviews
#69.4out of 10
Dan Kelly & Son Auto Sales
4077 Torresdale Ave, Philadelphia, PA
Google 4.7★ · 475 reviews
#79.3out of 10
Roll’s Auto Sales
6547 Frankford Ave, Philadelphia, PA
Google 4.7★ · 2,684 reviewsYelp 2.6★ · 30 reviews
#89.3out of 10
Citi Auto Group
4160 Torresdale Ave, Philadelphia, PA
Google 4.7★ · 489 reviewsYelp 3.3★ · 6 reviewsAdvertises buy here pay here
#99.3out of 10
Royal Car Center Inc.
3950 E Roosevelt Blvd, Philadelphia, PA
Google 4.7★ · 256 reviews
#109.2out of 10
Tacony Imports Auto Sales
6250 Torresdale Ave, Philadelphia, PA
Google 4.7★ · 129 reviews
#118.9out of 10
Liberty Imports Auto
4354 Torresdale Ave, Philadelphia, PA
Google 4.5★ · 286 reviews
#128.9out of 10
Arrow Motors Inc
2225 Wakeling St, Philadelphia, PA
Google 4.5★ · 256 reviews
#138.8out of 10
Mayfair Auto Sales
6900 Frankford Ave, Philadelphia, PA
Google 4.4★ · 663 reviews
#148.3out of 10
First Class Auto Land
4050 Frankford Ave, Philadelphia, PA
Google 4.2★ · 221 reviews
#158.2out of 10
Philly Auto
4530 Torresdale Ave, Philadelphia, PA
Google 4.2★ · 2,007 reviewsYelp 1.4★ · 73 reviews
How to use this list
- Shortlist two or three dealers near you.
- Read their newest 1- and 2-star reviews — look for patterns like hidden fees or title delays. How to read dealer reviews.
- Get pre-approved at a credit union so you have a rate to beat. Bad credit car loans.
- Ask each dealer for an out-the-door price in writing on the exact car.
- Have your own mechanic inspect the car before you sign.
Why a high Google score isn’t the whole story
Some lots have thousands of 5-star Google reviews but much lower Yelp ratings. Our score adds both together and starts every dealer with 10 “average” reviews, so a handful of perfect ratings can’t beat hundreds of real ones. See the full method. Dealers can’t pay to be listed or to change their score.
Ratings and review counts from Google Maps and Yelp, checked October 31, 2026. Scores are our editorial calculation; check each dealer’s current reviews before you visit. Spot a mistake? Tell us.