
A dealer usually costs a bit more, but handles title and tags, must post a Buyers Guide, and may offer financing. A private seller is often cheaper, but there’s no warranty and you handle the paperwork. Either way, inspect the car and check the title.
| Dealer | Private seller | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Higher | Often lower |
| Paperwork | Dealer handles it | You and seller at a PennDOT agent |
| Financing | Available | Bring your own |
| Rules | Dealer laws apply | Fewer protections |
Private sale in PA: quick tips
- Meet at a PennDOT-authorized agent to transfer the title and pay tax.
- Make sure the name on the title matches the seller’s ID.
- Pay with a cashier’s check at the agent, not cash in a parking lot.
Private sale checklist for Pennsylvania
- Check the seller’s ID matches the name on the title.
- Look for liens on the title — a lender listed means the loan must be paid off first.
- Run the VIN for history and recalls.
- Have a mechanic inspect it.
- Go together to a PennDOT-authorized agent to sign the title, pay sales tax (8% in Philadelphia) and get plates.
- Bring proof of insurance for the new car.
Financing a private sale
Many credit unions offer private-party auto loans. The lender usually pays the seller directly (or the seller’s lender) at the title transfer.
Risks of buying privately, and how to cut them
| Risk | How to protect yourself |
|---|---|
| Hidden mechanical problems | Independent inspection before paying |
| Lien on the title | Check the title; if there’s a lender, pay off at the lender or agent |
| Stolen car | NICB VINCheck; VIN on dash, door and title must match |
| Curbstoner (unlicensed dealer posing as owner) | Name on title must match their ID; be wary of several cars “for my cousin” |
| Payment scams | Pay at the PennDOT agent with a cashier’s check |
When a dealer is the better choice
- You need financing
- You want a warranty or certified car
- You don’t want to handle title work
- You need a trade-in
Quick questions
Do I pay sales tax on a private car sale in PA?
Yes. You pay it when the title is transferred at a PennDOT agent: 6% in most of Pennsylvania, 8% in Philadelphia.
Who keeps the license plate in a private sale in PA?
The seller. In Pennsylvania the plate stays with the owner, so the buyer needs new plates or a transfer of their own plate.
What is a curbstoner?
Someone who sells many cars without a dealer license, often posing as a private owner. They may hide problems or title issues. Check that the name on the title matches the seller’s ID.
Sources: PennDOT, “Buying or Selling Your Vehicle” fact sheet · FTC Used Car Rule.